Dyna Clone Transformers (triode vs. dynakitparts)

[snitch56]

I thought I would revisit this topic as it has been a while since it was last discussed.

I was wondering if anyone has a recommendation as to which transformers (triodeelectronics.com or dynakitparts.com) are better or am I just comparing apples to apples?

Here is what I can tell based on the two websites pictures:
The pictures at triode make the transformers appear scratched up and one of the mounting brackets is bent. Also, the wire leads from the A470 on the dynakitparts seem to either have a smaller gauge wire or thicker insulators (maybe PVC vs. Teflon?) compared to the triodes. The dynakitparts transformers look to be nicely finished with old iron labeling.

Any additional information related to sound, heat and quality of these transformers would be helpful.

Thanks in advance

[Uncle Ned]

The pictures at triode make the transformers appear scratched up and one of the mounting brackets is bent.

It's just a crappy picture. The transformers are fine.

Also, the wire leads from the A470 on the dynakitparts seem to either have a smaller gauge wire or thicker insulators (maybe PVC vs. Teflon?) compared to the triodes. The dynakitparts transformers look to be nicely finished with old iron labeling.

The question is whether the dynakitparts.com transformers are actually wound like a Dynaco or not. Their website is not entirely clear on the subject.

[TomMcNally]

I only have experience with the MK-III transformers from Triode - and they are beautifully finished, the leads are teflon and plenty long - the power transformer runs cool. I couldn't be happier with them.
The part numbers are painted, not stamped, which is OK with me.

I've used about 30 new transformers in projects over the last two years, and most of them do require bending the mounting ears flat with a pair of pliers, as they tend to get bent in shipping. I don't remember the Triodes specifically, but it's just one of the normal things that happens.